News
Beware of Backsliding
Earlier this year I was invited to deliver lectures at the Oztek and ADEX shows in Sydney and Singapore respectively. One of these was on “What Makes a Good Technical Diver” and I based my talk on the Scuba Confidential chapters “To the Extreme” and “Accident Analysis.” Because my audience, particularly at Oztek, was very experienced, I found myself extrapolating on some of the themes in the book. One of the topics I touched on that received a very positive response was the danger of new generations of divers not learning from their predecessors and consequently risking accidents that were entirely avoidable. I called this tendency “backsliding” and gave a few examples to explain what I meant.
Recently I was approached by a pair of technical divers and asked for advice on an incident that had befallen them on a wreck dive. One had experienced what seemed to be have been an oxygen toxicity hit and had needed to be rescued by the other, who had blown off deco to bring him up after he had convulsed and lost his regulator at 6m (20ft.) I asked for the details of the dive and they told me the wreck was on sand at 50m (165ft), they had been diving on air and carrying deco stages of 50% and O2. They had done a little less than 30 minutes on the wreck and on ascent had switched to EAN 50 at 20m and O2 at 6m. After only a couple of minutes at 6m the diver convulsed. Both survived the dive without any residual issues apart from a crisis of confidence.
I first asked if they were sure they were really at 6m when the convulsion occurred and they assured me they were. I told them that there was no history of a diver having had an oxygen toxicity event after such a short time on a PO2 of 1.6 in very shallow water. Therefore, the most likely cause of the incident was that the diver who had convulsed had made a mistake and switched to his O2 at 20m rather than his 50%. The diver said he was sure this wasn’t the case and recounted a whole list of things he had done that made this impossible. However, he admitted he had been up late mixing gas the previous night and had only had a couple of hours sleep as he needed to wake before dawn to drive to the dive site.
The Main Point
I leave it up to you to draw your own conclusions but to my mind the debate over whether the diver had got his cylinders mixed up or not is just a side issue here. The main point is that it was completely unnecessary for these divers to have been carrying two deco gasses in the first place. Either, EAN 50 or the O2 would have done the job just fine and having one gas would have had hardly any effect on the length of time they spent on ascent. They were in calm 30-degree water in the middle of the day after all: a few minutes extra on their hang were hardly going to be a safety issue.
In the early days of technical diving, breathing the wrong gas at the wrong depth was a common problem. Some divers survived; many did not. Labelling and other conventions were established to reduce the chance of this happening. However, human error being what it is, we figured at the time that the best way to make sure you do not switch to the wrong deco cylinder at depth is only to carry one. Except of course when time and safety requirements absolutely insisted that you carry more than one deco gas; for instance if your bottom gas was a hypoxic, helium rich mix.
Back to the Age of Ignorance
This is what I mean by backsliding: a return to practices and procedures that were rejected in the early days of technical diving as being likely to lead to accidents: a step backwards in the evolutionary process either through poor training and ignorance or because divers think somehow that they are too experienced to make mistakes.
Originally, the rise of technical diving coincided with the development of the Internet. Most technical divers happened to be early adopters of the new technology (we are all just geeks deep down!) and this meant that the technical community, though widespread geographically, was closely linked online. So news travelled fast! Especially bad news! Whenever a technical diving death took place, we would pore over the details, not out of morbid curiosity but to see if there were any lessons we could learn or if anything about the accident indicated that commonly adopted procedures might be flawed. When a flaw WAS found, things moved quickly, word passed around, training standards were amended and equipment was modified. This is how our sport developed.
New Ways or Old Ways?
As time passes and new generations of divers embrace technical diving I feel there is a danger that the incidents and accidents that led us to make changes in procedures in the past will be forgotten. Unless newer divers are told why we do things the way we do, there is always the likelihood that they may experiment with new ways that are really just the old ways – old ways that were found to be inherently dangerous so were rejected and replaced by safer ways.
You may think that I am making too much of a relatively minor incident. Unfortunately, divers do not usually tell anyone about their close calls, so this story actually gives us a rare insight that, I believe, is worth dwelling on and sharing. I remember thinking at the time, “I can’t believe that with all we have learned, with all the time that’s been spent over the years trying to improve safety in technical diving, that someone can still manage to get an O2 hit on a short 50m air dive! Where have we gone wrong? How come this sort of thing is still possible?”
More Backsliding
Others examples of backsliding I have seen over the last twelve months or so include: –
- Failing to make a dive plan for a technical dive and letting your dive computer vaguely plan the dive as you go, as per regular no decompression stop sport diving!
- Carrying independent back mounted doubles, one cylinder containing your bottom gas, the other cylinder filled with your deco gas! I don’t know how anyone could think that this is a fresh idea, yet it seems to crop up in different places from time to time as a new generation gets bored of carrying stage cylinders and looks for a lazy way out, not thinking that maybe the lazy divers of previous generations have already passed this way. This is a really easy way of breathing the wrong gas at the wrong depth, as many have found to their cost. It also, of course, completely takes away your bottom gas redundancy.
- Planning overhead environment dives using the rule of thirds but with only a single cylinder and K valve – again with no protection against an air supply failure and showing a complete misunderstanding of the gas rules.
- Diving a NITROX mix trusting the dive operator’s analysis and not checking the mix yourself. This one is becoming pretty much universal, especially on liveaboards.
I recognise that whenever I preach the virtues of past practices I risk coming across as an old fart bemoaning the folly of young people of today and insisting that “back in the day” we knew better. Nothing could be further from the truth. Progress is essential: we are nowhere near a perfect world as far as diving safety is concerned. The fact that every year we lose another friend or two to this sport is ample evidence of that.
Of course, a good technical diver does not remain so entrenched in the ideas of the past that he blinds himself to the opportunities of the future. But repeating the mistakes of the past is not the way forward.
News
Spooktacular Underwater Adventure: Oyster Diving’s First Halloween Scuba Party at Mercers Lake
Last Thursday, Oyster Diving transformed Mercers Lake into a hauntingly unforgettable underwater realm for their inaugural Halloween Scuba Party. Approximately 20 intrepid divers plunged into the darkness, weaving through a mesmerising scene of spectral decorations, glow sticks, and eerie underwater pumpkins.
After the thrilling night dive, participants gathered to feast on a ghoulish spread of pumpkin soup, chilli con carne, and decadent fudge brownies, perfect fuel for the frightful festivities.
With a resounding success, Oyster Diving is excited to announce plans for this event to become an annual tradition. Next year, look forward to a fully licensed bar and live music, promising an even spookier celebration under the moonlit waters.
Join us next Halloween for an experience that promises to be a haunting delight!
Find out more about Oyster Diving at oysterdiving.com.
Marine Life & Conservation
Shark Trust launches Oceanic 31 Shark Art Auction
After a two-year tour of UK art galleries, community spaces and aquariums, the Shark Trust’s acclaimed Oceanic31 exhibition takes its final bow at the Royal Geographical Society later this month. And the unique collection of artwork, depicting 31 species of oceanic sharks and rays, donated by 31 artists, is now open for bids from art lovers and shark enthusiasts. The online auction, launched today, will close on the 7th December at 8pm (BST). The money raised will support the Shark Trust Oceanics Programme.
People can now bid on 27 of the artworks by visiting this website:
https://superstars-auctions.com/sharktrustauction
It is a chance to own a beautiful piece of original art and to support the Shark Trust. The timing of the auction also means that these would make a very special Christmas gift for any shark-lover.
The diversity of pieces mirrors that of the sharks and rays they represent. You can bid on paintings, digital creations, sculptures, mixed media and more. You can pick your favourite artist or species of shark. Or you can select the perfect artwork to make a statement in your home or office. Whichever you choose, you will be supporting the work to protect these amazing animals.
One of the pieces of art has been selected to be auctioned live by Steve Backshall at the For the Love of Sharks event at the Royal Geographical Society in London on the 29th November. In addition to this, two further pieces will be raffled at this event, giving people a chance to win an incredible piece of shark art. For the Love of Sharks is the Shark Trust’s flagship evening. A night to celebrate sharks. Steve Backshall is the headline speaker at this event that will see other prominent shark advocates join him on stage.
Tickets for the event can be snapped up here:
https://thesharktrust.org.uk/Event/flos24
Those that would like to see the Oceanic 31 exhibition have one final chance. It is being displayed at the Pavilion at the Royal Geographic Society from 26th November until the 7th December. Entry is free.
Find out more here:
https://www.rgs.org/events/upcoming-events/oceanic-31
Paul Cox, Shark Trust CEO, Said “This exhibition has given us the opportunity to reach out to a new audience. And inspire more people with the wonderful sharks and rays on which our Big Shark Pledge campaign is based. We are immensely grateful to the 31 artists who have worked so hard to create these works.”
Bid for your favourite Oceanic 31 artwork here:
https://superstars-auctions.com/sharktrustauction
Banner Image: Smooth Hammerhead by Alicia Hayden
-
Blogs3 months ago
Gozo: An Underwater Treasure Trove in the Heart of the Mediterranean
-
News3 weeks ago
Iconic SS United States to become the World’s Largest Artificial Reef
-
Blogs2 months ago
NovoScuba’s Game-Changing Approach for Dive Store Owners: WE PAY YOU!
-
News1 month ago
Book Review – 52 Assignments: Underwater Photography
-
Marine Life & Conservation3 months ago
Book Review: Sharkpedia
-
Gear News1 month ago
DYNAMICNORD – New German diving brand enters the British market
-
News1 month ago
Exploring Cenote El Pit: A Diver’s Dream
-
Blogs3 months ago
Freediver Christian Redl Sets His 13th World Record at Lake Neufeld